17
When Franchising Goes Wrong
Posted by Mitchell York under Franchising
I like to think I walk the entrepreneurial talk. In addition to writing about entrepreneurship, I do it. I’ve been doing it for over six years in a national franchise. It’s been a long, sometimes painful, but now increasingly rewarding experience.
The franchisee base of which I am a part is a bell-curve of success–some people are killing it, some are getting killed by it, and most are somewhere in the middle. In the past week there has been an email thread going around from some of the people who are on the left side of the curve. One asks if anyone is interested in initiating a class-action lawsuit against the franchisor for selling them “a bill of goods,” for “disclosure issues,” for lack of support.
Over the years, many prospective franchisees have called me and asked my opinion of the franchise. They want me to tell them whether it’s a good idea for them to become a franchisee. My answer is always the same. I try to discourage people from buying this or any franchise. Not because I don’t like the business–I love it and it’s a big success for me. But people who seek affirmation from strangers to make the biggest financial investment of their lives are getting themselves in too deep. So it’s easier for me to tell people who are interested in this franchise (or others), one or more of the following things:
- Why do you want to buy this franchise? Are you running away from something?
- You’re going to invest $300,000 or more (for those who decide to open a retail store). How long will it take you to make that back, and what percentage return on that investment do you expect? How does that compare to taking the same money and buying a no-risk Treasury bill? Are you just bored? How about getting a job you like better than the one you just took a buyout from?
- Have you ever in your life done anything entrepreneurial? If not, what makes you think you will be successful with a franchise? And if you fail, what happens then? Will you lose your house? Your 401(k)? Your marriage?
One franchisee, who has become a valued business partner of mine doing profitable projects together, saw the email exchange and asked me, “What the hell is going on!?” I told her this: “Ignore stuff like this. Negativity = Failure. Positive attitude + action = Success.”
It is incredibly easy to psych yourself into a tailspin when you own a business. Or to raise yourself up and keep going until you find the formula, the business model, the customer set that works.
I’m a collector of franchising stories, so if you have one, good or bad, feel free to share.


August 17th, 2008 at 9:17 pm
Thanks Mitch. I really needed this as a reminder of how to be successful in MY business. Every once in a while we all need that little kick in the a$$ to get back on track. Thanks again.
August 21st, 2008 at 3:33 pm
Interesting to note is that the people failing want to blame the company rather than looking at what actions they aren’t taking to make the business successful. These may have been the same people who called you and asked “Should I do this?” I wonder why they aren’t now calling you saying, “How are you doing it?” That would be the smart question.
September 10th, 2008 at 10:40 am
Mitch, I love your insight. As a franchise consultant I always tell people, “be careful, just because you buy a franchise does not mean that you’ll make money. Just like joining a gym does not mean that you’ll automaticly get in shape - you have to work it!”
September 10th, 2008 at 6:05 pm
Aloha Mitch;
I’m with you. I’ve tried to talk “sense” to many prospective zees, usually with no success. They are caught up in the “glamour” of a franchise and the “freedom” of their own business. Having been a small business owner for 31 years prior to this one, I knew what I was getting into - work and more work initially. Now I’ve kind of “got it going on” in that all of my regular gigs are in the slot, and new ones are coming along with better profit margins. NOTHING happened because of the Mainland’s actions, positive or negative. I’m a big believer in being my own best marketing guru. So far, it’s working.